Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Søren Rasmussen's avatar

In my wayward youth it was considered terribly uncool to profess any enjoyment of the music of Barry Manilow or Abba, and (by an extraordinary lack of coincidence) this dismissive attitude was often held by the very same people who would browbeat the rest of the uncultured swine for not swooning over Joyce's Ulysses.

It was about that time I felt shamed into reading Ulyssses. Or rather, starting it. While I concede it is stylistically an impressive achievement, the experience left me very much less impressed by the sweeping pronouncement on quality or the lack thereof by the self-appointed gatekeepers.

I found that life was much better when you feel no pressure to be ashamed at enjoying a superbly crafted pop song, like many of those that flowed from the hand of Manilow or Andersson/Ulvaeus.

In fact, if pressed for my favorite disco song, I would most days pick the Donna Summer recorded version of "Could It Be Magic," which (along with the 1963 Dusty Springfield hit "I Only Want to Be with You") I consider near perfect examples of the best pop songs of their respective periods.

The whole experience did somewhat unfairly sour me on Joyce, with the result that it took some years before I picked up Dubliners, which I must admit is very good.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts