Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Søren Rasmussen's avatar

Agree with you completely re Spaceballs. It was meh back then. I saw it once when it came out and remembered it dimly through the decades since as a pretty mediocre and obvious cash grab, providing a few solid laughs and a lot of tired and unsurprising attempts at Star Wars jokes ("You remember Yoda. Well here's Mel Brooks as Yoghurt. See, it's like Yoda, only Yoghurt. Funny. And remember Han Solo And Chewbacca? Well, here's Bill Pullman and John Candy as Lonestar and Barf. He's a dog, see. Also, his name is Barf. Haha. Hey, why aren't you laughing out loud?").

I rewatched it for the first time a month or so ago. It was just as I had remembered it. A couple of good and funny jokes and a LOT of unfunny, obvious ones. Saying it did not hold up well obscures the fact that the original was never really that good to begin with. Certainly age has not been kind.

Meh is a good one word review.

And best bet is that the sequel will be a dud. Mel Brooks in his prime was a genius, but it would be very surprising if there is any of that left. And the people who are really doing the writing this time are extremely unlikely to be able to reach the toenails of the old Brooks.

Maybe it will be decent or even good, but that is not the way to bet.

The old cast wasn't even that good. Rick Moranis was good, but what a waste of John Candy. Bill Pullman was wonderful playing a moron in Ruthless People (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PS6lNDrCi88) but had nothing to work with on Spaceballs. Daphne Zuniga was pretty and boring and unfunny, and both Dick van Patten and George Wyner, both Brooksfilm regulars, were clearly going through the motions. Brooks himself was more manic than usual in his two roles as Yoghurt and the President, as if by trying harder he could make the dialogue funnier than it really was.

Pretty sure Joan Rivers was relieved she only had to supply the voice of the female droid and not have to show her face.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts